News Editor

Written by the news editors of The Independent this blog brings you the stories behind the headlines, the raw footage of events as they happen and an insider guide to the most interesting news from across the internet. Use the blog to contact the paper directly with your stories and comment on the major issues of the day.

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Oops...how The Telegraph got it wrong

Posted by Oliver Wright

Tuesday, 10 November 2009 at 11:02 am

Interesting to see that The Telegraph has taken down what was the main story in their newspaper this morning from the home page of their website .

The story claimed that Government was planning to ‘spy’ on every email, text message and website visit via a huge big brother database.

Anyone comparing the story with the front page of The Independent at newsstands this morning would be confused. Our story said the database was being cancelled.

So who was right? Well The Telegraph story was right – but only in October last year when The Independent first reported it.

What happened yesterday was that the government announced it was withdrawing the measure from the Queen’s Speech – delaying the database for at least a year and for far longer if, as expected, Labour lose the next general election. Privately ministers admit that the database is “in the very long grass”. None of this is reflected in The Telegraph story.

In general those of us in glass houses should not throw stones. But The Telegraph story was disingenuous – as anyone following the story knows.

Comments

( Leave a comment )

dogsolitude_v2 wrote:

Tuesday, 10 November 2009 at 12:19 pm (UTC)

Hmmmm.... Not sure who to believe now...

I'm off to have a coffee before it's banned.

Link | Reply | Thread

ron_broxted wrote:

Tuesday, 10 November 2009 at 01:54 pm (UTC)

Now look here, it is anarchist troublemakers like you who "rock the boat". I remain, Yours etc, K. Featherstonehaugh-MacCorquodale, Lt-Cdr, (R.N), Keeper of the Royal Goose, GCMC, VC and bar.

Link | Reply | Thread

littleglimmer wrote:

Tuesday, 10 November 2009 at 11:19 pm (UTC)

Yeah, Ronnie, that's what I told ya to write, sure 'nuff. Now git back on yore knees, boy.
Col Chuck Arseburger.

Link | Reply | Parent | Thread

Question just what constitutes a lie?

snotcricket wrote:

Tuesday, 10 November 2009 at 03:00 pm (UTC)

Didn't the government guarantee a referendum on EU treaties in their manifesto at the last general election? Only for the UK population to find that economics, & the truth have both been proved as beyond this motley crew called a Labour government, question just what constitutes a lie?

Didn't the government state they had cancelled the secret inquest proposal, we now find it literally passed under the radar, question just what constitutes a lie?

Why should we or the Independent believe the proposed 'spying' of emails etc has been cancelled?

If you really want to know what this government is upto listen what they say then look at what would be diametrically opposite to the statement & that's their true position.

Then when they knock on your door begging for your vote at the next general election little point in asking why you should trust them, just ask them the question just what constitutes a lie?

Link | Reply | Thread